Good info - thanks a ton! I appreciate the time you put into you posts. The good news is, I was able to cross a few things off the list.
I repaired the laminate:
The black laminate has a few hollow sounding spots, where the laminate isn't fully adhering. I re-secured it, but I may add some Tornado coasters on the corner that screw into the cabinet to secure it even better.
I shopped the cabinet, inside and out:
I was happy with the inside of the cabinet. There was evidence of 1 spill and it may have just been some silicone. I didn't see any swelling and overall appeared to be complete and in good shape. The balls, men, and playfield have been clean. I haven't done anything with the bearings yet.
This is a couple quick shots of it the gameroom:
You can see the condition of the rods in that last shot. I haven't had a chance to steel wool or clean the men in that pic. The men are clean but the rods still got some surface rust.
I had guests over for Christmas eve, and they seemed to struggle finding the ball on the track (I removed the ball ramp) so I set the coin mech to free play.
My next questions are:
Are the new bumpers worth it?
Are the new men worth it? Does that higher cross hatching really matter? I may have to get on a t-3000 to see what I think?
I have 2 rods I want to replace (the front 3 rows). Where would you order from? I'm in St. Louis, Mo. Not sure what local sources I have available.
I ordered new handles and clear side strips. I already have a few 5hr balls. I'm trying to decide if the expense/value of new men and bumpers is worth it.
Lastly, I'm adding a light, I just need to think of a way I can do it that it doesn't block the TV, or can be setup for game playing.
Appreciate all the help so far.